What to Ask a Toronto Nanny Before You Make an Offer

Twelve tips for Toronto parents interviewing nanny candidates: phone screens, real-day scenarios, C$23–C$39 pay talk, CRA payroll and vulnerable sector checks.

Quick answer

When interviewing a nanny in Toronto, ask them to plan one of your real weekdays, handle a specific behaviour scenario, explain their first-aid steps and describe how they report problems. Discuss pay of C$23–C$39 an hour, CRA payroll duties and a vulnerable sector check early, then finish with references and a paid trial.

The best way to interview a nanny in Toronto is to ask questions that make candidates describe real days, real problems and real records, rather than questions they can answer with a polished "yes". Plan for a short phone screen, a one-hour meeting at home, two reference calls and a paid trial session. Most Toronto families who follow that sequence complete the hire in two to four weeks.

AvailJob matches families with childcare staff across the Greater Toronto Area, and the same patterns come up again and again: the interviews that work are specific, the ones that fail are friendly chats that never test anything. The tips below are drawn from that matching experience. Each one ends with a single action you can take this week. If you are ready to start looking, the Hire a Nanny in Toronto page shows how to post a role and reach local candidates.

At the time of writing, AvailJob shows 0 open job listings in Toronto, so a well-written post with a clear rate has little competition for attention right now.

1. Run a ten-minute phone screen before anyone comes to the house

A full interview takes an hour of your evening. A phone screen takes ten minutes and filters out the mismatches: wrong hours, wrong commute, wrong expectations about pay.

Keep it to four questions:

  • Can you work the hours we need (for example, 8am to 6pm, Monday to Friday)?
  • Are you looking for live-in or live-out work?
  • What hourly rate are you expecting?
  • Are you able to work in Canada, and will you consent to a police information check with a vulnerable sector check?

If any answer is a clear no, thank them and move on. You are protecting both your time and theirs.

Action: Write those four questions on a card and use the same card for every call, so you can compare candidates fairly.

2. Ask for a role-by-role childcare history, not a summary

"I have ten years' experience" tells you very little. You want to know which ages, in which households, for how long, and why each role ended.

AvailJob suggests asking: "What ages have you cared for, and for how long in each role?" Then go one level deeper. If your youngest is eight months old, ask when they last cared for a baby who was not yet walking. If you have school-age children, ask about homework help and after-school activities.

Listen for gaps and for roles that ended quickly. Neither is automatically a problem, but both deserve a calm follow-up question.

Action: Sketch a simple timeline on paper as they talk. Any role you cannot place on it is a role to ask a reference about.

3. Give them one of your real weekdays and ask them to plan it

The suggested question "Walk me through a typical day you would plan for our children" works far better when you supply the real constraints. Describe an actual day in your house: wake-up time, nap windows, the school drop-off, the swimming lesson, the time you get home.

A strong candidate will ask clarifying questions before answering. They will build in outdoor time, reading, meals and rest without being prompted, and they will notice pinch points such as two pickups at the same time.

Here is the kind of brief to read out:

Time What happens in our home
7:30am Nanny arrives; parents leave by 8am
8:30am School drop-off for the six-year-old
10:00am–12:00pm Toddler at home; one nap expected
3:15pm School pickup
4:30pm Swimming lesson
6:00pm Parents home; handover

Action: Print your own version of this table and hand it over during the interview. Note what they add and what they question.

4. Put a public meltdown on the table

The AvailJob question "How would you handle a toddler's tantrum in public?" is useful because there is no single correct answer, only sensible and less sensible ones. You are listening for calm, safety first, and an approach that matches yours.

Good answers usually mention staying close, keeping the child safe, lowering their own voice, and not giving in to the demand that started it. Weaker answers rely on threats, bribes or embarrassment.

Follow up with a scenario from your own children: the sibling who bites, the five-year-old who refuses to leave the park, the baby who will not take a bottle from anyone except a parent.

Action: Write down two real behaviour situations from the last month and ask about those instead of an invented "perfect child".

5. Ask the date on the first-aid certificate, then ask how they would use it

AvailJob suggests "When was your first-aid training last renewed?" Paediatric first aid and CPR training sit at the top of the skills list for good reason. A date on a certificate is a start, but you also want to hear practical judgement.

Ask: "If our toddler chokes on a grape, what do you do first?" and "If our son has a high temperature at lunchtime, who do you call and in what order?" Clear, step-by-step answers show the training has stuck.

Also ask how they handle agreed medication. A good nanny will want written instructions, doses and times, and will expect to record what they give.

Action: Ask to see the certificate at the interview and make a note of the renewal date in your hiring file.

6. Settle screens and discipline before the children meet them

Many disagreements between Toronto parents and nannies trace back to two topics that were never discussed: screen time and consequences. AvailJob's suggested question, "What is your approach to screen time and discipline?", gets both on the table.

Share your house rules first, briefly, and then ask how they would apply them. A candidate who says "whatever you want" may be agreeable, but you also want someone who can explain their own view and adapt it to yours.

Topics worth covering:

  1. Daily screen limits and which devices are allowed
  2. Whether time-outs, loss of privileges or other consequences are acceptable
  3. How they praise and encourage good behaviour
  4. What happens when a child hits a sibling or another child

Action: Write a one-paragraph "house rules" note and give it to your final two candidates to react to.

7. Find out how bad news reaches you

Most families think about daily updates on meals, naps and moods. Fewer ask how a nanny delivers difficult news: a bump on the head, a fall-out at nursery, a problem with another adult.

The AvailJob question "How do you communicate with parents about problems?" opens this up. Strong answers describe a specific habit, for example a message straight away for any injury, a phone call for anything urgent, and a quiet conversation at handover for everything else.

Ask them for an example of a time they had to raise something awkward with a previous family, and how it went.

Action: Agree in principle on one channel for daily notes and a different one for urgent issues, and write both into the contract later.

8. Talk about pay in clear numbers, and do it early

Toronto's cost of living sits above the Canada average, and nanny pay reflects that. Avoiding the money conversation until the offer stage wastes everyone's time.

These are AvailJob's market ranges for a nanny in Toronto, not quotes:

Arrangement Typical pay (CAD)
Part-time (per hour) C$23–C$39 per hour
Full-time live-out (40 h/week) C$920–C$1,560 per week
Live-in (approx. 45 h/week, board included) C$880–C$1,492 per week
Temporary / agency C$28–C$47 per hour

Where a candidate sits in that range depends on experience, the number of children, extra duties, and whether evenings, weekends or public holidays are involved. Pay must never fall below Ontario's minimum wage.

Action: Decide your hourly figure before the first phone call, and state it in your job post so candidates arrive knowing it.

9. Say the word "employer" out loud

Families who hire a nanny directly in Canada are generally employers. That means registering a payroll account with the Canada Revenue Agency, deducting income tax, Canada Pension Plan contributions and Employment Insurance premiums, remitting them to the CRA, and issuing a T4 slip each year. The CRA explains this on its page about payments to caregivers, babysitters and domestic workers.

Raising this in the interview does two things. It shows candidates you intend to employ them properly, which experienced nannies value. And it lets you discuss whether quotes are gross or net, which avoids confusion later.

Hours, overtime, vacation pay and statutory holidays are set by Ontario's employment standards legislation, and the rules for live-in domestic workers have their own details. Confirm specifics with the CRA and the provincial employment standards office, or a payroll adviser, before your nanny starts.

Action: Tell each final candidate, in one sentence, that you will run payroll and issue a T4, and that you discuss pay in gross hourly terms.

10. Raise the background check before the trial, not after

For a role with children, the key check in Ontario is a police information check with a vulnerable sector check. Add identity verification and reference checks. AvailJob's checklist for this role also includes a first-aid certificate and at least two childcare references.

Candidates who work with children expect this. Mentioning it at interview stage, rather than springing it on someone after you have made a decision, keeps the process respectful and avoids delays.

If a candidate is coming through a federal caregiver immigration program or a work permit, there may be extra steps, including a Labour Market Impact Assessment and a named employer. The Government of Canada sets out in-home caregiver program requirements for families in that situation.

Action: Ask every shortlisted candidate when they can obtain or update a vulnerable sector check, and write the expected date in your notes.

11. Make reference calls with pointed questions

A reference call that ends with "she was lovely" has not done its job. Ask former employers about specific things you heard in the interview.

Useful questions:

  • How old were your children, and how long did they work for you?
  • What did a normal day with them look like?
  • Can you describe a time something went wrong and how they handled it?
  • How did they keep you informed?
  • Why did the role end, and would you hire them again?

Two references from childcare roles is the minimum. If a reference was a parent in Mississauga or Hamilton rather than central Toronto, that is fine; the questions stay the same.

Action: Use the same five questions for every reference so you can compare answers side by side.

12. End with a paid trial and a written contract

An interview shows how someone talks about childcare. A paid trial shows how they do it. Book a few hours, or a full day, when a parent is at home but not hovering, and pay for the time at the rate you discussed.

Afterwards, ask your children what they did and how they felt. Then sit down with the candidate and talk through what went well and what you would change.

If you go ahead, a signed employment contract should cover duties, hours, wages, overtime, accommodation if live-in, vacation and termination notice. Some provinces require or allow workplace safety insurance for domestic workers, so check Ontario's position with the provincial workers' compensation board.

Action: Put the trial date in the diary before you make an offer, and draft the contract headings now so you are ready.

Pulling your Toronto nanny interview together

Hiring a nanny in Toronto rarely goes wrong because of a lack of candidates; it goes wrong when the interview never tests the things that matter day to day. Keep the sequence tight: phone screen, home interview built on your real schedule, scenario questions, a clear pay figure, honest talk about being an employer, background checks, reference calls and a paid trial.

If you only need cover for evenings or the odd weekend rather than a regular nanny, look at Babysitter services in Toronto instead. Families in nearby Ottawa, Mississauga, Hamilton, London and Waterloo can use the same twelve tips, adjusting pay to local rates.

Whatever you choose, write down your questions before the first call, ask every candidate the same ones, and you will be able to make a fair, confident decision about the nanny who will spend their days with your children.

Hire a Nanny in Toronto

Post a free request and meet vetted candidates near you.

Get started →

Frequently asked questions

How long does it take to hire a nanny in Toronto?

Most Toronto families complete the process in two to four weeks. That covers posting the role, phone screens, home interviews, reference calls, the police information check with a vulnerable sector check, and a paid trial.

How many hours a week does a full-time Toronto nanny usually work?

Full-time nanny roles typically run 40 to 55 hours a week, covering the parents' working day. Part-time roles are often after-school care, usually from 3pm to 7pm on weekdays.

Should I pay a candidate for a trial day?

Yes. A trial is real childcare work, so pay for the hours at the rate you discussed. It also gives you a fair view of how the candidate handles your children and your routine.

Do I need to issue a T4 to my nanny?

If you hire a nanny directly in Canada you are generally their employer, which means deducting income tax, CPP contributions and EI premiums, remitting them to the Canada Revenue Agency and issuing a T4 slip each year. Confirm the details with the CRA or a payroll adviser.

Is a live-in nanny cheaper than a live-out nanny in Toronto?

AvailJob's market ranges put live-in roles at about C$880–C$1,492 a week for around 45 hours with board included, compared with C$920–C$1,560 a week for 40 hours live-out. Ontario's employment standards rules for live-in domestic workers should be checked before you decide.

What documents should a nanny bring to the interview?

Ask for identity documents, a current paediatric first-aid certificate and contact details for at least two childcare references. Explain that a police information check with a vulnerable sector check will be required before they start.

#nanny#toronto#ontario#nanny interview#childcare#hiring tips#household employer

Ready for your next step?

Browse open jobs or hire vetted domestic staff in 500+ locations.

Related articles